Inside Kathy’s Famous Cookies in Milford, with chalkboard menu walls, a chandelier and racks of bagged cookies

Kathy Klein was home with a 2-year-old and a 3-month-old in May 1999 when the advertising agency she’d worked at for 12 years handed her a pink slip. She says she made up her mind on the spot. “At that very split second (I kid you not), I said to myself that I would get my bakery license,” she writes on her shop’s website.

During nap times she made calls and researched how to sell cookies wholesale. She found a commercial kitchen, got her license, had a label printed, and in 2000 Kathy’s Cookies was in business. More than 25 years later, the shop now known as Kathy’s Famous Cookies sits at 1365 New Haven Ave. in Milford, near Adam’s Hometown Market, and the oven is still going all day.

The Kathy’s Famous Cookies storefront at 1365 New Haven Ave. in Milford, with the green BAKERY sign over the door

It started with one cookie and her mother’s kitchen

Klein didn’t set out to run a sweet shop. She planned to sell exactly one thing: mandel bread, a twice-baked Jewish cookie from her childhood that she’d been perfecting since she was 10. She told the shoreline magazine Daily Nutmeg in 2018 that she spent the first six years baking only that one kind of cookie.

“It’s not a bread at all, it’s just the very way you shape it and form it, it’s kind of in a flat loaf,” she told the magazine. “But I make it different than anyone else, … and everyone loved it.”

She credits her mother for the confidence. “My beautiful Mother always gave me free reign in the kitchen, and I took advantage of that,” Klein writes. When her parents had company, she told Daily Nutmeg, she’d be in the kitchen improvising on recipes, then bring out what she made. “I loved everyone saying, ‘Oh, Kathy, look what you baked!’” she said. “That’s how I did it. No one restricted me.”

That first cookie is still on the shelf. It’s sold as Molly’s Mandel Bread, named for her mother, a crunchy, cinnamon-y cookie with chocolate chips and almonds. Klein said many of the coffee houses she sells to simply call it cinnamon chocolate chip and almond biscotti.

Kathy Klein holding a tray of her cookies, cupcakes and biscotti

“Do you make other kinds of cookies?”

The menu grew one customer request at a time. A wholesale client at a Westport coffee house asked if she made other cookies. “I go, ‘Yeah, sure,’” she recalled. Chocolate chip, toffee, double chocolate and oatmeal followed. Then someone asked for biscotti. “Never made it in my life!” she said. She looked up recipes, tested them and tweaked them until she was happy, and did the same with muffins and scones. Everything is her own recipe, made from scratch, her website says.

For a while she shared a kitchen and storefront with a custom cake baker. Then she moved into what she called a “totally hidden spot” on Melba Street. Most of the business was still wholesale, “but people found me,” she said. Some of those people never left. “I have been a long time supporter of Kathy’s Cookies, ever since they were on Melba Street,” a customer named Amelia wrote in a Google review.

In November 2018, Klein cut the ribbon on the current shop on New Haven Avenue, with then-Mayor Ben Blake on hand. Inside, the walls are painted chalkboard black and covered in hand-lettered pink menus, there’s a sparkling chandelier overhead, and racks of bagged cookies fill the middle of the room.

What to order

A giant cookie. These are the reason most people walk in. The daily lineup includes chocolate chip, toffee chocolate chip, double chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, peanut butter, macadamia white chip, lemon sugar, cinnamon sugar and funfetti. Trish wrote in a Google review that she drove about 30 minutes because she’d heard about the place. “The cookies are huge so I ordered three to share with my family,” she wrote. “However, I ended up eating one of them all by myself on the ride home.”

A box of oversized cookies from Kathy’s Famous Cookies in Milford, including chocolate chip, double chocolate and funfetti

Toffee chocolate chip. If you only buy one, Klein makes the case for this one. On her site she calls it the shop’s most requested cookie, the one people “drive for miles” for and “reserve dozens of bags” of, and says it was featured on a popular reality TV show for three seasons. Which show? She writes that she can’t say, because of a contract.

Biscotti. Most are coated in chocolate, and the flavors run from pistachio chocolate chip and papaya coconut to Almond Joy, lemon white chocolate, salted caramel and a gluten-free chocolate chip. Frank wrote that Klein “has to be the Willy Wonka of cookies and biscotti,” adding that her biscotti “is like biscotti on steroids!! Ridiculously large and flavorful!”

A pile of chocolate-dipped biscotti at Kathy’s Famous Cookies with the shop’s “THIS is Biscotti!” flavor card

Cupcakes. Big ones, topped with pure buttercream or cream cheese frosting. Regulars include vanilla bean, deep chocolate, carrot cake, red velvet, “Funny Bones” filled with peanut butter buttercream, a cream-filled “Hostess” and cannoli-filled cupcakes. There’s even Ivor’s Special Gingersnap, named for a customer the shop says is “addicted” to them.

Lemon cupcakes with lavender buttercream at Kathy’s Famous Cookies
A peanut butter cupcake with a swirl of frosting from Kathy’s Famous Cookies

Scones, muffins and bars. The scones come in flavors like cranberry-orange-almond, maple walnut and lemon poppy, and the menu promises they’re moist. There are crumb-topped muffins, lemon squares, ganache-topped brownies and big layered crispy treats. This month the shop showed off a 10-inch cookie cake, three inches deep, and peanut butter brownies on its Facebook page.

The bakery case at Kathy’s Famous Cookies filled with cookies, bars and treats

What locals say

The shop has a 4.8-star rating from 132 reviews on Google, and the shop writes back to its reviewers. Several reviewers talk about the cookie trays. Rebecca ordered one for her son’s high school graduation party, “thoughtfully decorated in school colors,” and wrote that “it was a pleasure doing business with Kathy and her crew.”

Amelia said Kathy’s is her go-to for events like teacher appreciation week, “as I know how much everyone loves the cookies.” She also wrote about a favor that stuck with her: “Kathy kindly donated cookie trays to support the Foran HS Music Department at their event. I was so impressed with her generosity and support.”

Frank summed it up: “If you’ve never heard of Milford, CT — you’ll never forget it once you visit Kathy’s Famous Cookies.” His only regret, he wrote, was “not pulling up to her store with a U-Haul.”

If you go

Kathy’s Famous Cookies is at 1365 New Haven Ave., Milford, in the plaza with Adam’s Hometown Market. Its website lists hours of 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. Saturday and 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. Sunday, though it calls them “just a guide” and says, “If the open sign is [on] we are here!” Things can sell out, so call (203) 878-5712 to reserve something specific or to order a cookie tray, which the shop bakes to order. With Thanksgiving a week away, that’s worth knowing. Kathy’s packaged cookies and biscotti are also sold at a number of local markets and coffee shops; the website lists Cafe Atlantique in downtown Milford among them.

More from our Sponsored Partners
Milford Voice may be paid a small commission on partner offers at no cost to you.

Get Milford’s best stories first — subscribe to the free Milford Voice newsletter

Have a tip? Email news@milfordvoice.com

We make local businesses and events look incredible. 30,000+ monthly readers in Milford and nearby, 8,500+ weekly email subscribers, 27,000 in What’s Going On in Milford. Advertise with us.

By Milford Voice News Team

Local news for Milford, Orange, Stratford and West Haven. Got a tip? Email news@milfordvoice.com

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *