Bruno’s Wood Fired Apizza grand opening at 17 Wagner Place in West Haven, with the ribbon cutting in front of the shop

West Haven has a new wood-fired apizza shop, and it comes with a family name a lot of Connecticut pizza eaters already know. Bruno’s Wood Fired Apizza opened at 17 Wagner Place on Thursday, Nov. 12, in the old Gusto Bakery space near Main Street and Kelsey Avenue. Owner Christopher “Bruno” Bernardo cut a “Westie blue” ribbon that day with Mayor Dorinda Borer, his wife, Selene, and three of their five daughters beside him.

“We are thrilled to welcome Bruno Bernardo and his authentic wood-fired pies to West Haven,” Borer said at the ceremony, which was organized by the Milford Regional Chamber of Commerce. “Our city loves great food, and Bruno and the entire Bernardo family are a wonderful addition to our business community.”

“I love West Haven,” Bernardo told the crowd. “Thank you for all the support!”

A family that grew up in the pizza business

Pizza is not a new line of work for this family. Bruno’s own website puts it plainly: “Pizza isn’t new to us. It’s in our blood.” Bernardo has spent a lifetime on New Haven-style apizza — the thin, crisp, charred pies people around here pronounce “abeetz” — carrying on the work of his parents, Luigi “Gigi” and Catherine Bernardo, who ran Gigi’s Pizza in New Haven’s Fair Haven neighborhood.

The family story does not stop at Wagner Place. Bernardo’s three brothers are in the business too. Arsenio Bernardo runs New Haven Pizza Place in Milford, Frank Bernardo runs the New Haven Pizza Truck, and Luigi Bernardo Jr. runs the Little Italy Pizza Truck, according to the city’s account of the opening. For Milford readers, that means a familiar name has a new shop one town over, and the family is still making pies the way they learned at home.

Two pizzas baking inside the wood-fired oven at Bruno’s Wood Fired Apizza in West Haven

The heart of the newly renovated shop is an Italian-style, 7-by-7-foot Forno Bravo wood-fired oven. Bernardo has said that oven is what gives the pies their char. In the kitchen on opening day, cooks Freddy Saucedo and Alex Gahona were there for the ribbon cutting, according to the city’s photo caption. Up front, Selene and daughters Christine, Brianna and Rosina wait on tables and take the to-go orders. It is a family operation, start to finish.

A few days around the opening, the shop posted a thank-you on its Google listing: hundreds of people had already walked through the door, and the family asked for patience while they found their groove. “We’re a family-owned business with a whole lot of heart, and nothing makes us happier than serving the community we love,” they wrote. “From our family to yours, THANK YOU for being part of our journey! We’re just getting started!”

What to order

The menu is built around New Haven-style pies, with gluten-free crust available on request. There are traditional reds and whites, calzones, stuffed breads, wings, subs and a list of specialty pizzas. Bruno’s also sells pizza flights — three or four small cheese pies, each with one topping — for people who want to try more than one thing at the table, and it offers dine-in, takeout and catering.

The mashed potato, caramelized onion and bacon pizza coming out of the wood-fired oven at Bruno’s in West Haven

The pie people keep talking about is the Bernardo-style mashed potato pizza: mozzarella, bacon, potato and a white sauce, with caramelized onions, pulled from that oven with the kind of char Christy Allington said “didn’t taste burnt at all, just that nice char flavor.” She ordered it for opening weekend, went straight for the darker edge, and called the bottom of the pie perfect — thin, with a soft chew. Mikeleena Cavallaro’s family tried the mashed potato pizza on opening day, too, along with the artichoke and bacon pie and a chicken parm sub she said was a lot larger than she expected.

A white wood-fired pizza at Bruno’s, finished with greens and lemon

Kayla Warren came in for a classic cheese pie and the artichoke, bacon, lemon and hot honey pizza — the Artichoke Bacon pie on the shop’s ordering menu, finished with Mike’s Hot Honey and lemon. “I genuinely cannot stop thinking about that combination,” she wrote. “The flavors were unreal, everything was fresh and delicious, and you can tell there’s so much care put into the food.” She called Bruno’s her new go-to pizza spot.

Patrick Fallon split a pie, half sausage and garlic and half regular cheese, and added a small artichoke bacon. “A nice new gem for West Haven,” he wrote. “Love the family.” Other specialties on the live menu include broccoli rabe and sausage, clams casino, clams garlic, shrimp casino, a veggie special, BBQ chicken, and Bruties 3 Alarm, a pepperoni and buffalo chicken pie with Mike’s Hot Honey. The New Haven-style original is a simple red pie with garlic, olive oil and pecorino romano. A margherita comes red or white.

Wood-fired pizzas on the table at Bruno’s Wood Fired Apizza

If you are not in the mood for a whole pie, stuffed breads are $19.50 on the ordering menu, in versions like meatball mozzarella, chicken parm, spinach and sausage, and fresh tomato and bacon. Calzones come with ricotta and mozzarella. Wings are sold in 7-, 14- and 21-piece orders. There are garlic knots and garlic bread, and a dessert case of cake slices, listed at $6.19, plus Italian cannoli at $2.34. Cheese slices are $3.12, and a meat slice is $4.16.

A stuffed bread from Bruno’s, sliced on butcher paper with a cup of sauce
Cake slices in the dessert case at Bruno’s Wood Fired Apizza

The early reviews, and a shop that’s still finding its groove

Bruno’s is barely a week old, and already it has a 4.7 rating on Google from 66 reviews. The people who have been in since opening day keep coming back to the same things: the pies, the oven, and how the family treats you.

“From the moment you walk in, you feel welcomed and right at home,” Courtney Lane wrote. “It’s the kind of place where you’re treated like family, not just another customer.” Kayla said the staff was friendly and the service was quick. Christy, who ordered two hours ahead on the first Friday because she knew the shop would be slammed, ran into a mix-up on a half-and-half pie. The people at the counter apologized, offered a discount, and she left happy anyway. “Mistakes happen but they handled it so well, above and beyond,” she wrote. “I will definitely be a returning customer not only for the food but for the wonderful customer service and kindness.”

The entrance to Bruno’s Wood Fired Apizza, decorated with grand-opening balloons

If you go

Bruno’s Wood Fired Apizza is at 17 Wagner Place, West Haven, around the corner from Elm Street and Sawmill Road. The phone is (203) 239-0881. Hours, confirmed on Google on Wednesday and matching the city’s announcement, are Tuesday through Thursday, 11 a.m. to 9 p.m.; Friday and Saturday, 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.; and Sunday, 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. The shop is closed Mondays. You can look at the menu and order ahead at brunoswoodfiredpizza.com.

More from our Sponsored Partners
Milford Voice may be paid a small commission on partner offers at no cost to you.

Get Milford’s best stories first — subscribe to the free Milford Voice newsletter

Have a tip? Email news@milfordvoice.com

We make local businesses and events look incredible. 30,000+ monthly readers in Milford and nearby, 8,500+ weekly email subscribers, 27,000 in What’s Going On in Milford. Advertise with us.

By Milford Voice News Team

Local news for Milford, Orange, Stratford and West Haven. Got a tip? Email news@milfordvoice.com

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *