Scarpellino’s Restaurant and Catering — Milford CT’s Italian Restaurant Worth Knowing About

What to Order at Scarpellino’s Restaurant and Catering

• Italian Breakfast Sandwich — A morning-shift staple, loaded with the kind of ingredients that make a simple egg sandwich feel like an event.
• Hot Grinders — Scarpellino’s grinders are the real draw for the lunch crowd. Stuffed generously and built on solid bread, these are the kind of sandwiches that haunt you after you leave.
• Pasta Dishes — Available during lunch hours, the pasta offerings bring the restaurant’s Italian roots front and center — straightforward, satisfying, made with care.
• Catering Platters — For office orders or family events, the catering menu brings Scarpellino’s kitchen to your table. Italian cold cuts, hot entrées, and sides that travel well.
• Daily Specials — The kitchen rotates specials that reward the regulars who show up consistently. Worth asking about when you walk in.

The Atmosphere at Scarpellino’s Restaurant and Catering

Scarpellino’s draws a crowd that reflects its neighborhood — tradespeople grabbing a hearty breakfast before a job site, office workers swinging by for a grinder on their lunch break, and longtime customers who’ve been coming in for years. There’s an easy, familiar energy here that you can’t manufacture. It’s a working-person’s restaurant in the best possible sense — efficient, generous, and genuinely glad you walked in.

The midweek lunch rush is real, so if you’re planning a catering order or a group visit, calling ahead is the move. The space isn’t enormous, but the turnover is steady and the wait — if there is one — moves quickly.

Insider tip: Scarpellino’s closes at 2:00 PM sharp, so plan accordingly. Showing up at 1:45 PM with a big catering order in mind isn’t the way to make friends — call (203) 468-7827 ahead of time and they’ll take good care of you. Parking is available on-site, and the location on Forbes Avenue is easy to reach from both Milford and the surrounding New Haven area. Weekday mornings are the sweet spot if you want a quieter visit and first pick of whatever’s fresh.

Have you been to Scarpellino’s Restaurant and Catering? Drop your go-to order in the comments and share this with someone who still thinks Italian food only happens at dinner.