The Arciuolo's Shoes storefront at 74 S. Broad St. in downtown Milford, with its script sign, striped awning and a "CT's Foot Pain Experts" sign out front

If you grew up in Milford, there’s a good chance someone at Arciuolo’s Shoes knelt down, pressed a thumb against the toe of a new pair and told your parents you had room to grow. The store on South Broad Street, along the Milford Green, has been run by the same family since 1921, and it calls itself Connecticut’s oldest shoe store.

Today the man behind the counter is Matt Arciuolo II, the fourth generation of the family to sell shoes in Milford. He started at the store in 2005 and has owned it since 2017. “This was the only thing I ever wanted to do — I never wanted to be an astronaut or a fireman; I’ve always wanted to do what my dad did,” he told Milford City Lifestyle.

The Arciuolo’s Shoes sign over the store’s side entrance, behind a white picket fence

A shoemaker’s son from Puglia

The story starts with Francesco Arciuolo, who came from a long line of cobblers and shoemakers in Monte Sant’Angelo, in Italy’s Puglia region. His first son, Matthew, was born there in January 1918. In 1920 Francesco brought the family to Bridgeport, and in 1921 he opened a shoe store on Naugatuck Avenue in Milford’s Walnut Beach neighborhood, selling shoes and fixing them, according to the family’s history of the store.

Then came heartbreak. Francesco died suddenly of a heart attack at 35, the family says, leaving his wife, Nancy, with five children and a young business. Matthew, still a boy, stepped up. By 13 he had left school to work in the shop full time, selling and repairing shoes while his mother ran the store and his sister Madelyn handled the money.

Matt Arciuolo smiling in front of a wall of shoes at Arciuolo’s Shoes, beside an old framed family portrait

He kept the doors open through the Great Depression and into World War II, when he was drafted and served as a quartermaster. When he came home, Milford City Lifestyle reported, anti-Italian feeling was hard on Italian American families and businesses, so for a while the shop went by another name, The Wildemere Shop. When things eased, the Arciuolo name went back up.

Matthew married his sweetheart, Pauline Serravalle, in 1946, and the couple ran the store together. He also served the city as a volunteer firefighter.

The day a customer asked for orthotics

The family’s favorite story is about a word Matthew didn’t know. A customer asked him for a pair of orthotics. He said yes anyway. That evening, the family says, he walked to the library, looked up “orthotic” in the dictionary and taught himself how to make them. Custom arch supports became a core part of the business, and before long he was filling prescriptions from area doctors. When Milford’s jai alai fronton drew professional players from around the country, many of them found their way to his shop with sore feet.

A vintage family photo from inside Arciuolo’s Shoes, with two generations of the Arciuolo family posing among the shoe displays

His son, Matt Jr., was born in November 1958 and started at the store at 11, washing windows and sweeping floors. He learned fitting and orthotic work from his father, graduated from the University of Bridgeport and took on a bigger role at the store. In 1989 father and son moved Arciuolo’s downtown to its current home at 74 S. Broad St. Matt Jr. became a board-certified pedorthist, and in 2001 he started Footstar Orthotics, the family’s custom insole brand, which still works out of the store.

Some of the old tools are still in use. Milford City Lifestyle described a Brannock foot measurer about 50 years old, wooden shoe stretchers, and a grinder Matthew built himself around the motor from a 1938 Westinghouse washing machine. “We have six backups just in case, but the original has yet to need any servicing or maintenance in nearly 100 years — so we’re set for the next 600,” Matt II told the magazine.

From Broad Street to Olympic gold

In the mid-2000s, the U.S. Olympic bobsled and skeleton teams started coming to the family for custom orthotics. Then the coaches asked whether the Arciuolos could make their athletes faster.

“They told me that if I could get them one-thousandth to two-thousandths of a second faster in the push before they jump into the sled, that is the difference between not even placing and winning a gold medal,” Matt Jr. told Fairfield University’s magazine this spring.

He built a carbon-fiber insole, and at the 2010 Winter Olympics in Vancouver the U.S. men’s bobsled team won gold, its first in 62 years, with his insoles in their shoes, the magazine reported. That insole grew into VKTRY Gear, which Matt Jr. and his wife, Felicia, started in 2015. Its headquarters is in Milford, about two miles from the shoe store, and their son Drew runs its marketing.

Two men at Arciuolo’s Shoes look over a colorful digital foot-pressure scan and orthotic model on a large screen

Still a family fitting

For all the Olympic talk, the store is still about regular Milford feet. The shop says its staff is “made up of friends and family that are trained fitting experts,” and every customer gets measured. Matt II is a board-certified pedorthist too, and Milford City Lifestyle reported that what he finds most rewarding is making footwear for people with hard-to-fit feet.

“When your feet hurt, everything hurts,” he told Milford City Lifestyle.

What to shop for

Everyday and running sneakers. A long wall of athletic shoes from brands like New Balance, Brooks and Saucony, alongside dress and casual shoes from names like Clarks and Florsheim. Expect someone to measure your feet before you try anything on.

A long wall of athletic sneakers on display at Arciuolo’s Shoes in Milford

Kids’ shoes. The store says it carries shoes for the whole family, “especially children,” and there’s a play area and a fish tank to keep little ones busy during the fitting.

The fitting area inside Arciuolo’s Shoes in Milford, with rows of seats, a fish tank and walls of Clarks, Florsheim and Saucony shoes

Winter boots. With cold weather coming, there’s a wall of boots and winter footwear, UGGs included.

Boots and winter footwear, including UGG, on the wall at Arciuolo’s Shoes in Milford

Custom orthotics. This is the family specialty. The store offers a free orthotic evaluation with a pedorthist. Footstar’s in-store workup includes pressure mapping, foot scans and gait analysis, and the shop takes doctor referrals and HSA and FSA payments.

A pair of Footstar custom orthotic insoles, black on top with a light blue base

Socks, insoles and shoe care. The counter is stocked with socks, insoles and care supplies, and customers say the staff will give your shoes a shine.

The front counter at Arciuolo’s Shoes under hanging lamps, with socks, insoles and shoe-care supplies on the walls

What customers say

Arciuolo’s has a 4.8-star rating on Google from 69 reviews, and the newest ones read like thank-you notes.

Susan wrote last month that her husband’s health had declined to where he could barely walk, and specialists hadn’t helped for long. A co-worker suggested Arciuolo’s, and they ordered custom shoes. “From the moment he put them on he could feel an immediate improvement and is walking in a way I have not seen in years!!” she wrote. “If I could give 10 stars I would!”

Aaron stopped in the day before his wedding to get his shoes shined. “They treated me like family,” he wrote. “Not only did they get the shine perfect, they surprised me with some shoe-care supplies as a wedding gift.”

Isaac called it “simply in a league of its own.” “The staff is incredibly knowledgeable, patient, and genuinely invested in making sure you leave with the right shoes—not just a sale,” he wrote. “At this point, it’s the only place our family shops for shoes.”

Joshua said Matt “was extremely helpful and provided great service from start to finish,” and added a detail regulars will recognize: “they even had an adorable dog in the store which made the visit even better.” And Brandon, who admitted he hasn’t needed new shoes in years, still called the shop “a staple of Milford” run by “some of the city’s greatest people.”

If you go

Arciuolo’s Shoes, 74 S. Broad St., Milford. Google lists hours of 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Saturday, closed Sunday; with Thanksgiving next week, call ahead at (203) 877-7463. Orthotic appointments can be booked at arciuolos.com.

More from our Sponsored Partners
Milford Voice may be paid a small commission on partner offers at no cost to you.

Get Milford’s best stories first — subscribe to the free Milford Voice newsletter

Have a tip? Email news@milfordvoice.com

We make local businesses and events look incredible. 30,000+ monthly readers in Milford and nearby, 8,500+ weekly email subscribers, 27,000 in What’s Going On in Milford. Advertise with us.

By Milford Voice News Team

Local news for Milford, Orange, Stratford and West Haven. Got a tip? Email news@milfordvoice.com

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *