Three friends who grew up on Italian sandwiches, the thin cutlets, the cold cuts, the Sunday gravy, decided Milford needed a deli that tasted like home. So they built one at 575 New Haven Ave. in Corso Plaza. R&M Cutlet Co. calls itself “an old school Italian deli but with new school flavors,” and since its soft opening at the end of 2025 it has quickly become a regular lunch stop for plenty of Milford sandwich lovers.

The partners are Matt Nittoly, a longtime school administrator in Norwalk; Ryan Trevethan, chef-owner of The Plate in the same plaza; and Michael Hazzard, a carpenter who rebuilt the inside of the former Yani Natural & Organic store. Nittoly called the project three friends with “a strong passion for food and community” when he talked to Patch around the opening.

Nani’s meatballs and Missy’s Best

Nittoly learned to cook at his grandmother’s side when he was 10, he told CT Insider. Her meatballs, served for decades at Sunday dinners that “brought the whole family together,” are on the menu now. After Fairfield University he went to culinary school, then spent 27 years in education.

What finally pushed him to open the deli was a conversation with his sister, Melissa Dowd, shortly before she died of cancer. “Listen, if I have any advice for you, time is short. Do what you want to do now,” he remembered her saying. The cold-cut sandwich called Missy’s Best is hers: prosciutto di Parma, sharp imported provolone, marinated roasted peppers, pickled red onion and garlic aioli, “built from love, memory and a little extra prosciutto.”

Trevethan brings the restaurant kitchen experience, which Nittoly said was “really an area where I needed the help.” Hazzard’s carpentry is all over the room.

Inside R&M Cutlet Co. in Milford, with shelves of Italian sauces and pantry goods under framed black-and-white photos

A deli that looks the part

Walk in and you get framed black-and-white portraits of Italian-American icons over shelves of jarred peppers, sauces, pastas and oils for the mini market. The menu reads like a family album crossed with a mob movie: How You Doin’, Goombah, The Stugots, Luca Brasi. “Our entire menu is really a combination of names and stories related to each of our families or pop culture things in Italian movies,” Nittoly told CT Insider. There is a rotating hot food bar, too, and the restaurant’s website shows a Best of Milford 2026 winner badge.

“Our sandwiches, hot food bar, and mini-Italian market offerings are inspired by the people, movies, TV shows and culture that shaped us growing up; mainly Italian-American things that made us laugh, gather and feel at home,” Nittoly told Patch.

Every sandwich comes on your choice of a club roll, a white or wheat wrap, a salad, or a 12-inch wedge or seeded semolina for $2 more. All but one land between $11.95 and $14.50, according to the July 2026 menu; the exception is the $17.95 Mama Mia Steak & Cheese.

Portions are big. The Nutmeg Millennial called the cutlets “thin, tender, and flavorful with a little crunch” and said one sandwich makes “enough for at least two meals.” The writer admitted the sandwiches are “kind of expensive,” then argued the leftovers make up for it. The deli also runs monthly specials; May’s was “Cinco de Cutlet.”

What to order

The Bada-Bing ($13.95)

This is the one reviewers keep bringing up. A crispy cutlet with crispy prosciutto strips, burrata, pickled red onion, arugula salad and hot honey. It runs sweet and salty at once, and as the photo shows, half a sub is a serious amount of food.

Half of a Bada-Bing sub from R&M Cutlet Co., stacked with crispy breaded cutlets and greens on a seeded roll

The Parm on seeded semolina ($12.95, plus $2)

The Parm comes with your pick of a cutlet or meatball, done classic parmesan style with red sauce and melted mozzarella. Order it on the seeded semolina, which holds up to the sauce. If you want to branch out, A “Tate” of Italy ($13.50) pairs meatball and sausage with basil pesto, and the Mama Mia Steak & Cheese ($17.95) is the priciest thing on the board, served on a 12-inch wedge only.

A hot parm-style sandwich with melted mozzarella and red sauce on a seeded semolina roll from R&M Cutlet Co.

A cold-cut sub

Not every order needs a cutlet. Trev’s Trio ($13.50) stacks roasted turkey, Black Forest ham and roast beef with Swiss and tomato bruschetta, and Gramp’s Italian Combo and Missy’s Best are $13.95 each. For the roast beef crowd, The Stugots ($13.95) adds fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers.

A cold cut sub from R&M Cutlet Co. layered with sliced turkey, ham and roast beef on deli paper

Any cutlet as a wrap

For a lighter lunch, most sandwiches can come in a white or wheat wrap. The Uncle June ($13.95) is built for it: chopped crispy cutlet, parmesan, romaine and crispy prosciutto, wrapped and grilled in a flour tortilla.

A chicken cutlet wrap from R&M Cutlet Co. filled with lettuce, tomato and sauce

The word around town

R&M holds a 4.6-star rating across 84 Google reviews, with chicken cutlets, subs and friendly staff the most-mentioned topics. Michael summed up his first order: “The sandwich I received was the bomb (the Haz), packed with flavorful ingredients, great size and overall thoughtfully crafted.” The Haz ($13.50) pairs a cutlet with broccoli rabe, melted provolone, cherry peppers and balsamic glaze. Not every review is glowing; one diner called the prices steep. But Haley noticed how the owners handle a miss: “The owner Matt reached out to me and we had a nice conversation where he took ownership for their mistakes and short comings.”

Catering is a big part of the business, too. Cutlets and meatballs run $14.99 a pound, and trays of chicken and sausage scarpariello, chicken parm and baked ziti are on the catering menu. R&M is closed Mondays, so plan your cutlet craving accordingly.

KEY FACTS

Business: R&M Cutlet Co.

Address: 575 New Haven Ave. (Corso Plaza), Milford, CT 06460

Hours: Tue.–Fri. 10 a.m.–4 p.m.; Sat.–Sun. 10 a.m.–3 p.m.; closed Mon.

Phone: (203) 257-5456

Prices: Sandwiches $11.95–$14.50, except the Mama Mia Steak & Cheese ($17.95); seeded semolina +$2; cutlets or meatballs $14.99/lb.

Web: rmcutlet.com (downloadable menu)

Owners: Matt Nittoly, Ryan Trevethan and Michael Hazzard

Reader poll: Which R&M cutlet sandwich would you try first?

Get Milford’s best stories first — subscribe to the free Milford Voice newsletter

Got a tip? Email news@milfordvoice.com

Photos: Colin C via Google; Greg Longo via Google; Rick Jurzyk via Google; MilfordLady via Google; Post Road via Google.

We make local businesses and events look incredible. 30,000+ monthly readers in Milford and nearby, 8,500+ weekly email subscribers, 27,000 in What’s Going On in Milford. Advertise with us.

By Milford Voice News Team

Local news for Milford, Orange, Stratford and West Haven. Got a tip? Email news@milfordvoice.com

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *